I seriously doubt it's the OS...
Right!
It is a test of not only the OS.
Linux will use a different set of things to interface to the Wireless device. Now there just might be small chance the device was
not installed correctly under Windows . Linux will load in about 2 or 3 minuets and you will have a way to compare relative performance.
Live Linux does not alter the original installation, so it is a non-destructive test. Otherwise, doing the Windows Wireless install is time-consuming and can change things in a way that is hard to reverse. A system restore in Windows can take twenty minuets.
And yes. there is the possibility that Linux can not even install the wireless device. But if one already has a Linux Live in his toolbox, it only takes a few minuets to give it a try.
This is about a Live Linux, not a full install.
Avoid the full install. Unless you like adventure.
BTW: Many 'Rescue CDs' are built from
Live Linux.