My primary experience is with building custom OS's utilizing the Linux kernel. Yet I also have considerable experience with MS products. I was recently asked by a friend about reimage.com.
I did a google search and found their website, and this thread among other threads concerning Reimage.
Upon my initial search of their websites and various links. My untangle server lit up showing blocked events by the Phish Blocker. In other words their website was attempting to install software by just going to their website. Check the wikipedia on Phishing if you are not familiar with it.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PhishingFor those of you unfamiliar with what Untangle is. If you have a unused box handy. I highly suggest using Untangle or some other server to filter and control your internet access. You will be amazed at the amount of spyware that is blocked. It is a very dangerous world out there, and more so when using a MS OS.
http://www.untangle.com/After reading this thread I thought I would add my two cents!
Both Broni and PC_Programmer ran the service with a new install. In both cases they were alerted of sever problems. NicholasBlack response was:
"Our software is designed to fix dysfunctional PCs, not new ones (that's why our tagline is "PC Repair, In Minutes", rather than boosting it)"
It is certainly plausible that a clean install can have corrupted files or missing files. The results posted by Broni clearly does not allude to missing or corrupted files. The results only refer to problems that would cause fear. It is obvious that fear is what Reimage is primarily using to drive sales. Even if Reimage shuffles the wording of their results. Their primary objective will still be to drive sales by the use of fear. In sales fear is the best motivator to get people to sign on the dotted line.
Reviewing their website and reading responces from NicholasBlack. What exactly the installed software does, is not clearly defined. Removing applications that are listed does not ensure that all software has been removed. A hidden application could certainly still be present after removing their visible applications. NicholasBlack is a marketing rep, not a software engineer. He is not involved with the actual coding at all. Therefore he is not qualified to make statements concerning how their software works. Nor would he be aware of what exactly the software does, as he has to rely on what he is told. Which may not be the truth or the whole truth.
NicholasBlack claims that (about 100,000 PCs already fixed and 10 million images in our repository).
With 10 million images in their repository they have access to everything on your hardrive. Therefore there is a big concern about what they are doing with those images. In other words, a script can be written to search all those images to find and list all personal information. Which brings to mind, is Reimage compiling personal information? With my experience with the Phishing on there website. It is clear that their intention is to collect personal information. Not to mention that Israel has one of the largest espionage programs in the world. No better way to get data on people than have them leave an image of there hardrive on their servers, and get paid for it!
In closing it is very simple. If you do not want people looking at your personal information on your computer, do not allow someone access. Through out history people have used the ploy, we will help you, while their real intentions are other wise. Even if Reimage intentions are not malicious, and they do not sell or use your personal information. Their government can certainly demand access to their image repository, any time they want. Do you want some countries government to have all your personal information?
The simplest solution to problems with MS products, is do not use them. There are numerous alternative OS's that are far more capable, and demonstrate better security than MS products.