Thank you for your response, Geek. I really appreciate your time.
Here's what I've done:
I have since tried another CD RW drive (the computer has 2, but I disconnected one to make it as bare bones as possible until this gets figured out).
The CD RW drive works fine.
I have also tried another CD (Darin's Boot and Nuke) and it will not allow me to boot to that CD either. I can boot to that cd on my other computer, and to the Windows XP CD that I have (on the other computer, not the one in question).
I have connected both CD RW drives (one, then the other, not both at the same time) by the main IDE connection on the board, and the secondary IDE connection on the board in case one of the IDE connections on the board itself was bad. I have also tried another ribbon in case it was faulty.
The computer has (2) 512 sticks of RAM in it, so I have also tried removing the secondary, and then switching out the primary and secondary sticks, and I'm still in the same spot.
I have double checked all of my connections to the board and to the SATA hard drive and to the CD RW drive.
I have also looked for bulging capacitors on the board, but they all look good.
I'm a software guy, but these are things I have found to check from talking with others
I'm truly at a loss here.