I agree. That is part of the reason I am not in the CH chat very frequently. It's either I sit there and say nothing, sit there and help somebody and end up having an argument with somebody else about how "wrong" my advice was, attempt to correct somebody saying something that is provably false or perhaps dangerous and then have an argument about that, or wait until I'm the only one offering advice at all and end up having to try to help 5 people simultaneously- to the detriment of whatever else I'm trying to do....
Then get occasionally told how bad my advice was hours later when the "smart people" show up again, as if I didn't have anything better to do with my time.
That said, the "log" segment above doesn't really provide a lot of context, and could be edited in some way. Not pointing fingers and saying it's Doctored, just that this sort of thing is difficult to backup outside of a more complete log.