Actually this is the 3ed hard drive iv echanged for, so im sure its not that, I tried using fdisk off a fresh HD, I used drive zero to erase everything, start fresh, create the partiton, make it active, exit fidisk and I get "cannot save to fixed disk" I am really thinking its a hardware problem, ide cable or something. But it saves the partitions when I use the recovery disk, and it loads the OS. So its saving some info the hard drive.