Just because the PSU works with less load doesn't necessarily mean it isn't bad- there might be something wrong with the PSU that prevents it from properly supporting the full load when you plug in the motherboard.
It could still be the motherboard, but all the evidence (including your "testing method" described in your last post) seem to point to the PSU.
Especially since no fans or anything turn on...
if you try what D3m0sth3n3s said, you'll be able to KNOW wether it is the mobo or not- if you have the same problem with a new PSU, it's the motherboard, otherwise it was the PSU.