Think I got it. At least it is doing what I want. Anyone have a cleaner way to do this, post for all to enjoy.
if exist File2 del file2
setlocal ENABLEDELAYEDEXPANSION
set count=0
for /f %%v in (File1) do (
set /a count=!count!+1
echo !count!
if !count!==3 echo %%v > File2
if !count!==5 echo %%v >> File2
if !count!==10 echo %%v >> File2
if !count!==70 echo %%v >> File2
if !count!==71 echo %%v >> File2
if !count!==72 echo %%v >> File2
)