a) Windows XP was running fine for probably 6+ months; I was using it mostly for gaming, MSN, homework, web browsing, normal stuff.
b) I have a legit XP home, copied XP pro, and my friend lent me a XP home legit CD which we had used to install XP on his computer a few days prior.
c) Not to sure what you mean by same controller, my motherboard only has 2 IDE slots, one for primary one for secondary. HD jumpers are set to master, CD set to slave. Not to sure what you mean here Mac.
d) Going to the XP cd and doing my formatting and partitioning from there is what i'm trying to do; however, it won't load properly and freezes before i can get anywhere with it.
e) Yes, i did have SP2 & all updates. I went out for a couple days, my sister phoned to ask if she could use the computer to download music for our grandmother's mp3 player, I said ok, got back and she said it had been acting weird so she shut it off. This is when I found the problem. The crash was basically this; hardware would load, and XP would go to the "windows shut down improperly, safe mode, ect." screen... i would select an option, or let it choose automatically, and instead of loading the computer it would restart and start the whole chain over again.
f) formatting to ntfs; but if i had to settle for fat32, i REALLY wouldn't care ;P