Sorry, I can not post a print screen for some reason.
When I go to the device manager and open the "monitors" folder I see the words "Generic PnP Monitor". I did try to update the driver, but it is telling me that my drivers are up to date. I was unsure what would happen if I hit the disable or uninstall options, so I did not do either of those things.
I notice that your print screen shows the 2 monitors the same size. I am not sure if this matters, but for my #2 monitor, it shows it to the right, and about 3/4 of the size of the #1. It allows me to move these, but it then makes them both smaller but they still have the same resolution numbers.
Clearly I have no idea what I am doing. I hope I am not screwing up too badly.