Sidewinder, that's brilliant! Your are a genius!
I could not duplicate what he did. That explains it!
The command interpreter always looks in the current directory for a fie before looking into the PATH. That also explains why it was so quick. Finger can take a few seconds. But the command interpreter did do invoke the real finger executable, instead recursively called the bat file name 'finger'.
Kind of like taking two mirrors and looking at your face...face...face...face...face.....