So then, shall we conclude that -
Anyone who offers a
so-called legal alternative
to lime-wire
is telling a lie? -anonymous
That is not acceptable.
Assuming that there is no money being traded for the items, then yes.
An advertising based version of Limewire may be what the industry needs to gain a margin profit from something like Lime/Frostwire. Any program giving you 'free' anything is either freeware, supported by donations/advertising, or illegal.
Have to crack/patch it? illegal
If you have to use a File sharing program in order to acquire the album, then it is most definitely illegal. A free album would be released on easily accessible channels, more likely the band's site itself.
Gambling is using your own capital anyway.
Piracy is more like gambling with the companies money, losing it all, and just walking away.
The last "legal" shared file for the public I heard of was a torrent copy of "Sintel"
http://www.sintel.org/